'Lying in broad daylight': Trump slammed for falsely claiming he isn't 'allowed' to testify at hush money trial due to gag order

Justice Juan Merchan, who is overseeing the trial, hit Trump with a gag order to prevent him from making public remarks about potential witnesses
PUBLISHED MAY 3, 2024
Former president Donald Trump claimed that the gag order on him would stop him from testifying in his defense in the hush money trial (Getty Images)
Former president Donald Trump claimed that the gag order on him would stop him from testifying in his defense in the hush money trial (Getty Images)

MANHATTAN, NEW YORK: Former President Donald Trump came up with a false claim about the gag order against him in the ongoing hush money criminal trial.

Speaking to reporters outside the Manhattan courthouse on Thursday, May 2, the GOP presumptive nominee baselessly said he was "not allowed" to testify in the trial because of the gag order, according to Newsweek.

Justice Juan Merchan, who is overseeing the trial, hit Trump with a gag order to prevent him from making public remarks about the potential witnesses. However, the ex-president violated it multiple times, causing Merchan to issue a $9000 penalty over his frequent public attacks against trial witnesses on the Truth Special platform.

In response to the prison threat for the transgression of the gag order, Trump removed the social media posts on April 30.

(Juan Merchan/LinkedIn)
Justice Juan Merchan ordered Donald Trump to pay $9000 for violating the gag order (Juan Merchan/LinkedIn)

Trump's false claims about gag order

While addressing reporters outside the courtroom, Trump was asked when he would take the witness stand in the hush money trial.

"Well, I'm not allowed to testify, I'm under a gag order I guess, right?" Trump responded while briefly turning to his attorney, Todd Blanche, who nodded in agreement with his client's false claim.

"I can't even testify ... No, we're going to be appealing the gag order. I'd love to answer that question ... but I'm not allowed to testify," the White House hopeful whined. Trump also criticized the court, calling it "rigged" and the gag order "unconstitutional."

"We're appealing the gag order and let's see what happens," he added.



 

In April, Trump declared he would testify and "tell the truth" in the criminal trial that stemmed from his attempt to cover up the hush money payment to adult film actress Stormy Daniels during the final days of the 2016 election campaign to silence her about the alleged affair. He faces 34 charges for falsifying the business records to pay the $130,000 to Daniels through his ex-attorney Michael Cohen

Legal experts quickly disagreed with Trump's baseless assertion, pointing out that Justice Merchan's gag order against the defendant did not prevent Trump from taking the witness stand.

LAS VEGAS, NEVADA - JANUARY 26:  Adult film actress/director Stormy Daniels attends the 2019 Adult V
Donald Trump allegedly paid $130000 to Stormy Daniels in exchange for her silence about their alleged sexual encounter (Getty Images)

"The gag order has nothing to do with that," attorney Karen Friedman Agnifilo said on CNN. "Of course [Trump] can testify. He has an absolute right to testify, and he is not restricted in terms of what he can talk about as long as it's relevant, admissible evidence," she continued, adding that the gag order "only talks about statements outside of court."

Internet slams Donald Trump

Lashing out at Trump over his false claims, netizens said the ex-president was lying.

One user said, "This is what we call lying in broad daylight." Another remarked, "Uh that's a blatant lie and he has ever right to testify in his own defense. The gag order has nothing to do with testifying."



 



 

"Trump really thinks his voters are stupid ... just unbelievably stupid," one user fumed. Another response read, "What an imbecile, not to mention a liar."

Another user added, "Showcasing eternal victimhood again!"



 



 



 

Someone else argued, "This is just another damn lie, by Trump, for talking points to his propagandist liars, who will then spew this lie to the MAGA cult! No gag order stops Trump from exercising his constitutional right to testify on his behalf! His attorney is also a damn liar, in agreeing with him!"

"He's not only a liar of the highest order, but a moron too thinking he could say this w/ no consequences or followup. The Judge is now obligated to question him to make sure that he understands he has an absolute right to testify or not testify, and that the gag order is no bar," an individual wrote.

Another outraged remark read, "Such a liar and a coward!"



 



 



 

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

MORE STORIES

After likening Trump’s immigration tactics to Nazi Germany, Illinois Governor JB Pritzker denied ever comparing him to Adolf Hitler
2 days ago
Melania Trump reportedly distanced herself from President Donald Trump’s East Wing renovation, privately questioning the historic demolition, WSJ reports
2 days ago
Donald Trump expressed willingness to work with Democrats while noting that the Affordable Care Act, aka Obamacare, has 'been terrible'
4 days ago
Trump also brought up an incident from 30 years back when Mikie Sherrill was not allowed to participate in her graduation ceremony
5 days ago
Bernie Sanders said, 'So long as we have nation-states, you’ve got to have borders. If you don’t have any borders, then you don’t have a nation'
5 days ago
John Fetterman told Sean Hannity he’s fed up with his party painting Republicans, and especially Trump, as racists, Nazis, or fascists
7 days ago
George Santos says Zohran Mamdani's takeover of City Hall would turn New York City into a 'very dangerous place'
Oct 22, 2025
Chuck Schumer said that things are getting worse every day for the American people
Oct 22, 2025
Robert De Niro said Trump 'is not going to leave the White House' and urges Americans to 'strap on their balls and do something about it'
Oct 20, 2025
The new aircraft is to be used to replace an older plane flown by Kristi Noem
Oct 20, 2025