Republican strategist Karl Rove offers brutal take on Donald Trump's 'catastrophic' debate performance

Karl Rove believes Donald Trump's performance in the debate with Kamala Harris was far worse than anything his team could have imagined
PUBLISHED SEP 12, 2024
Karl Rove bared his thoughts on the Donald Trump-Kamala Harris debate in a Wall Street Journal op-ed (Getty Images)
Karl Rove bared his thoughts on the Donald Trump-Kamala Harris debate in a Wall Street Journal op-ed (Getty Images)

WASHINGTON, DC: Karl Rove, who served as deputy chief of staff during George W Bush's presidency, excoriated former President Donald Trump's debate performance against Vice President Kamala Harris.

In a Wall Street Journal op-ed, the Republican strategist described the event as nothing short of a "train wreck" for the GOP nominee.

Republican presidential nominee, former U.S. President Donald Trump and Democratic presidential nominee, U.S. Vice President Kamala Harris greet as they debate for the first time during the presidential election campaign at The National Constitution Center on September 10, 2024 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. After earning the Democratic Party nomination following President Joe Biden's decision to leave the race, Harris faced off with Trump in what may be the only debate of the 2024 race for the White House. (Photo by Win McNamee/Getty Images)
Donald Trump and Kamala Harris debated for the first time during the current election cycle on Tuesday, September 10 (Win McNamee/Getty Images)

Karol Rove's analysis of Donald Trump's 'catastrophic' debate performance

Karol Rove labeled Donald Trump's performance during the Tuesday, Septmeber 10 debate as "catastrophic." He went so far as to say that Trump was "crushed by a woman he previously dismissed as 'dumb as a rock.'"

According to him, the former president's showing was "far worse than anything Team Trump could have imagined."

PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA - SEPTEMBER 10: Republican presidential nominee, former U.S. President Donald Trump speaks to reporters in the spin room after debating Democratic presidential nominee, U.S. Vice President Kamala Harris, at Pennsylvania Convention Center on September 10, 2024 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. After earning the Democratic Party nomination following President Joe Biden's decision to leave the race, Harris faced off with Trump in what may be the only debate of the 2024 race for the White House. (Photo by Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images)
Karol Rove believes Donald Trump allowed himself to be dominated by his anger during his debate against Kamala Harris (Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images)

Rove claimed Trump was "visibly rattled" as Harris "launched rocket after rocket at him." An analysis by The New York Times revealed that the Democratic nominee spent a whopping 46 percent of her time on offense, compared to Trump's 29 percent.

"Debates aren’t won on defense," declared the 73-year-old.

Digging deeper, Rove insisted that Trump's emotions got the better of him - a flaw Harris exploited to full advantage.

"He took the bait almost every time she put it on the hook, offering a pained smile as she did," wrote Rove, adding, "Rather than dismissing her attacks and launching his strongest counterarguments against her, Mr Trump got furious."

Things only deteriorated for Trump as the debate wore on, according to Rove. "He gripped the podium more often and more firmly. He grimaced and shook his head, at times responding with wild and fanciful rhetoric," further noted the political consultant. 



 

In Rove’s view, Trump failed in his most critical task, tying Harris to President Joe Biden’s policies. Instead, Trump allowed himself to be dominated by his anger.

"It matters how debating candidates carry themselves. There, it was no contest. Ms. Harris came across as calm, confident, strong, and focused on the future. Mr Trump came across as hot, angry, and fixated on the past, especially his own," highlighted Rove. 

"She mastered the split screen, projecting confidence and wordlessly undercutting him by smiling while shaking her head as he spoke," noted the Republican, commending Harris' performance. 

While Rove acknowledged that the debate would have an impact on the election, he tempered his analysis with a dose of realism. He concluded that the debate's effect might not be as significant as Harris’ team might hope or as disastrous as Trump’s team might fear.

"But there’s no putting lipstick on this pig," remarked Rove, adding, "Mr Trump was crushed by a woman he previously dismissed as 'dumb as a rock.' Which raises the question: What does that make him?"

Donald Trump thinks he 'won' the debate

True to form, Donald Trump wasn’t shy about defending his performance. Appearing on Fox News' 'Fox & Friends' on Wednesday, the former president insisted that he "did a great job" during the debate.

He also accused the moderators, ABC News' David Muir and Linsey Davis, of being biased toward Harris. 

"It was three on one. It was a rigged deal, as I assumed it would be, because when you looked at the fact that they were correcting everything and not correcting with her," said Trump, accusing Harris of lying "six or seven times" without being called out by the moderators.

He even went as far as to suggest that ABC News should lose its license over how it handled the debate. "They’re dishonest. I think ABC took a big hit last night," remarked the GOP nominee. 



 

Despite the criticism and the less-than-stellar reviews, Trump remained defiant. He declared, "I’ve been told I’m a good debater. I think it was one of my better debates, maybe my best debate."

The idea of a second debate with Harris quickly became a hot topic, with Trump claiming that his opponent was pushing for it "because the loser always asks for a rematch."

He further stated, "I won the debate. I don’t know if I want to do another debate."

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The map, which was passed with a vote of 57-41, redraws Indianapolis into four districts
2 hours ago
Donald Trump said his admin is 'seriously' studying Australia’s employer-funded retirement system as a possible model to strengthen US savings
3 days ago
House Republicans backed Trump’s Venezuela strikes but urged the White House to provide clearer plans after a follow‑up attack killed survivors
3 days ago
RFK Jr hailed the end of ‘20-year war on women’ as he said that removing black box warnings on hormone therapy would expand access for millions
4 days ago
Donald Trump said that he had aced his medical exams as he floated a plan to abolish federal income tax and replace it with tariffs
4 days ago
Republicans debated Donald Trump’s economic ideas as Rand Paul cautioned that tariffs and investor optimism could trigger a severe correction.
5 days ago
Democrats push for 'HIRE Act' to double H‑1B visas, sparking GOP backlash, as the bill can raise the annual cap to 130,000
7 days ago
Trump called himself the ‘affordability president’ in a medicine‑price post as he claimed that invoking Favored Nation rules drove historic drops
7 days ago
Donald Trump defended tariffs and warned of ‘evil forces’ at the Supreme Court as he urged justices to uphold his emergency powers
7 days ago
Elissa Slotkin’s comment about the federal troops was based on the alleged comment Trump made
Nov 29, 2025