Stephen Baldwin reveals bizarre reason he was fired from Jennifer Aniston movie

Stephen Baldwin said he had originally been cast as Jennifer Aniston’s boyfriend in the film, which also starred Paul Rudd
According to Stephen Baldwin, a producer approached him after the second day of shooting and expressed concern that he was being 'funnier than Jennifer' (Getty Images)
According to Stephen Baldwin, a producer approached him after the second day of shooting and expressed concern that he was being 'funnier than Jennifer' (Getty Images)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: Stephen Baldwin has made a very wild accusation years later, after being fired from a classic Jennifer Aniston movie for outshining her.

During a recent episode of his podcast ‘One Bad Movie’, the 60-year-old actor revealed that he was the first choice to play the A-lister’s boyfriend in the 1998 film, ‘The Object of My Affection’.

Actor Stephen Baldwin attends the world premiere of
Actor Stephen Baldwin attends the world premiere of 'Waltzing With Brando' at TCL Chinese Theatre on September 15, 2025 in Hollywood, California (Photo by Michael Tullberg/Getty Images)

Stephen Baldwin says he was asked not to be 'funnier than Jennifer'

The rom-com also starred Paul Rudd. But Baldwin was fired just two days after the shooting.

“After the second day of shooting, after lunch this producer comes to my trailer and goes, ‘There's a problem.’ He goes, ‘You can't be funnier than Jennifer,’” he shared.

The ‘Born on the Fourth of July’ actor then recalled telling the producer, “Is this a joke? This is a comedy movie!”

Stephen Baldwin's role was given to John Pankow

Baldwin returned to the movie set the next day after the incident while trying “not to be me”. But things did not work in his favor and he was replaced with ‘Mad About You’ star John Pankow.

Stephen Baldwin attends Sandals Resorts Hosts Private Event in Support of the Sandals Foundation at Hyde Lounge for Sabrina Carpenter's LA Concert at Crypto.com Arena on November 20, 2025 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Vivien Killilea/Getty Images for Sandals Resorts)
Stephen Baldwin attends Sandals Resorts Hosts Private Event in Support of the Sandals Foundation at Hyde Lounge for Sabrina Carpenter's LA Concert at Crypto.com Arena on November 20, 2025 in Los Angeles, California (Photo by Vivien Killilea/Getty Images for Sandals Resorts)

However, the father of Hailey Bieber clarified during the podcast that he’s shared the story not to “shred anybody”. He even claimed that he still does not know who directed that his acting be questioned.

TJ Miller enjoyed working with Jennifer Aniston

Baldwin shared the story with TJ Miller on the podcast. Miller worked with Aniston in ‘Office Christmas Party’ and had a very good experience with her.

Jennifer Aniston arrives at an FYC event for
Jennifer Aniston arrives at an FYC event for "The Morning Show" on Sunday, June 7, 2026, at the DGA Theater Complex in Los Angeles (Photo by Jordan Strauss/Invision/AP)

The two played brother-sister in the 2016 movie and at the time Miller had said, “We had brother-sister chemistry. I was really surprised because I had heard about you and what a terror you were. I heard that you were very sweet, but I thought, ‘How do we establish this chemistry?’ And so quickly you were welcoming and you were like, ‘Well, here, text me and let’s try to have a dinner.’”

“The chemistry was there already because she was a little sisterly to me on set, in a sense of ‘Hello, little baby wannabe-movie-star fellow, I’m going to look out for you,’” the 45-year-old added.

NEW YORK, NY - FEBRUARY 09: Actor TJ Miller attends the AOL Build Speaker Series - Ryan Reynolds, TJ Miller, Ed Skrein and Morena Baccarin,
Actor TJ Miller attends the AOL Build Speaker Series - Ryan Reynolds, TJ Miller, Ed Skrein and Morena Baccarin, 'Deadpool' at AOL Studios In New York on February 9, 2016 in New York City (Photo by Jim Spellman/WireImage)

Meanwhile, Baldwin never got another chance to work with the ‘Friends’ star. He, however, worked in movies like ‘The Usual Suspects’, ‘Threesome’, and ‘Bio-Dome’.

He also did TV and appeared in shows, like ‘I'm a Celebrity...Get Me Out of Here!’, ‘The Mole’, ‘Celebrity Big Brother’, ‘The Celebrity Apprentice’, and ‘Special Forces: World's Toughest Test’.

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

During an appearance on the 'Unfamous' podcast, Katy Perry candidly revealed that she has been feeling 'angry' and is 'wrestling with my darkness'
2 hours ago
Jeremy Clarkson reflected on surgery, recovery and an uncertain future
2 hours ago
Colin Farrell referred to Tom Cruise as 'what an engine' and noted that his enthusiasm on set was contagious
3 hours ago
Jelly Roll filed for divorce from Bunnie Xo in Tennessee on May 18, citing irreconcilable differences after nearly 10 years of marriage
3 hours ago
Ann Dowd recalled being shocked by Donald Trump's 2016 election win and said she immediately texted Elisabeth Moss after reading the news
4 hours ago
Seyfried said she can share her opinions but did not expect the strong reaction. She also said she is not sorry for her comments
4 hours ago
Kourtney Kardashian detailed a terrifying pregnancy complication after previously experiencing three easy pregnancies
5 hours ago
A source claimed Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce plan to keep their wedding private, with a small circle of friends and a focus on privacy
6 hours ago
According to Jeremy Allen White, the two actors worked separately throughout production and did not share scenes or spend time together on set
6 hours ago
Armie Hammer said he was 'pretty sure' he cried after landing a role in 'Citizen Vigilante', his first acting offer in five years
6 hours ago