Stephen Colbert gives hilarious response to Trump’s ‘what do you have to lose’ question for New Yorkers

Trump’s rally in Long Island was part of his efforts to sway New York, a state known for its Democratic leanings
Stephen Colbert gave a list of things New Yorkers might lose if they vote for Donald Trump in the upcoming election (Getty Images)
Stephen Colbert gave a list of things New Yorkers might lose if they vote for Donald Trump in the upcoming election (Getty Images)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: Donald Trump recently asked voters of New York, “What do you have to lose?” if they vote for him in the upcoming election. Stephen Colbert seems to have found the answer to this question.

During his opening monologue on 'The Late Show', the CBS host delivered a comically long list of what’s at stake.

Trump held a rally at Nassau Coliseum on Long Island on Wednesday, September 18.

“I say to the people of New York, with crime at record levels, with terrorists and criminals pouring in and with inflation eating your hearts out, vote for Donald Trump,” he said.

“What the hell do you have to lose?”

Stephen Colbert comes up with list of what’s at stake for New Yorkers

“What you’ve got to lose,” Stephen Colbert began, mockingly adjusting his glasses.

“Democracy, reproductive rights, sanity, the environment, the Department of Education, the ability to look your grandchildren in the eye, the ability to wear a red hat ever again, support from our allies, and the strategic McNugget reserve.”



 

Trump’s rally in Long Island was part of his efforts to sway New York, a state known for its Democratic leanings.

At the rally, Trump claimed he would win over the traditionally deep-blue state, despite losing it by 23 points in both the 2016 and 2020 elections.

“Oh, people love you in New York, sir,” Colbert joked. “In fact, just this summer Trump won a unanimous vote from 12 of his peers.”

Colbert was in a particularly playful mood, also discussing the 'White Dudes for Harris' ad campaign while adopting the persona of Tony Pepperoni', a caricature focused on casual interests like “getting some brewskis and wings” and voting freely.

This bit featured a mix of Chicago and Brooklyn accents, with Colbert exclaiming, “Go f**k yourself” and getting into faux altercations over a woman named Brenda.

Stephen Colbert channels Joe Biden to mock Donald Trump

Stephen Colbert even showcased his Joe Biden impression.

After airing a clip of Trump discussing 12-cent White Castle burgers, the camera returned to Colbert in aviator sunglasses.

“What the heck? Jack, y’all kicked me out of the race for talking about old guy stuff — you know, pony soldiers and alley cats. But he gets to stay in even though he’s talking about 12-cent burgers?” Colbert quipped as Biden.

“Back in my day, a burger cost you a button and a half.”

Former President Donald Trump made several verbal gaffes during the Philadelphia MAGA rally (Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)
 Stephen Colbert pointed out the challenges he faces in the 2024 race, especially after being endorsed by controversial candidates (Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)

Shifting gears, Colbert touched on the election landscape, mentioning that while Kamala Harris has been surging in the polls, “your vote doesn’t matter unless you’re in a state that swings.”

He humorously pointed out the challenges Trump faces, particularly with his endorsement of controversial candidates like Mark Robinson, who has made inflammatory comments in the past.

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Donald Trump criticized Barack Obama's Iran nuclear deal and his support for Democratic candidates during the 2026 midterm campaign trail
2026-10-26T06:10:52.000Z
Donald Trump defended private health insurance, citing satisfied friends and claiming that some of his Canadian friends travel to the US for medical treatment
2026-10-26T06:05:14.000Z
President Donald Trump renewed his claim that he deserved the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize after human rights lawyer Navi Pillay was named the winner
2026-10-26T05:38:59.000Z
Thom Tillis also accused Democrats of 'gaming the system' through the candidacy of Daniel J Sullivan
2026-10-26T05:12:13.000Z
Elon Musk's money has gone toward efforts to boost Republicans in key races, particularly Texas Senate candidate Ken Paxton
2026-10-26T04:47:42.000Z
Amy Acton urged Donald Trump and JD Vance to examine the facts, recalling her testimony against her stepfather over childhood abuse
2026-10-26T04:16:27.000Z
Donald Trump criticised Bill Maher’s appearance and HBO show after the comedian described their latest meeting and defended dining with the president
2026-10-26T02:59:54.000Z
Donald Trump attacked Michigan Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed, calling him a 'Muslim Brotherhood member' and demanding metal detector screening if elected
2026-10-26T02:36:02.000Z
Gretchen Whitmer, former VP Kamala Harris and other women are widely speculated to be potential candidates in the 2028 Democratic presidential primary
2026-10-25T21:55:26.000Z
Attorney General Todd Blanche refused to identify whom Trump meant when he claimed he ordered a DOJ lawsuit over Alaska's Senate race
2026-10-25T20:46:10.000Z